I DRMed This Post

I have a DVR.  It allows me to record a program I don’t have time to watch and it can pause a program for up to an hour, if I’m called away from the television. So far, so good.  Its convenient as hell, but I, like countless others, quickly discovered the biggest advantage of all:  No commercials.  During the NFL season, I’d record the game, go about my life, and then later, watch a three hour game in roughly 45 minutes, by simply “fast forwarding” what I recorded.  Part of me struggles with this, as I wonder how ethical it is for me to enjoy provided content without allowing those that provided it a chance to earn my business.

I do the same thing with other favorite shows.  I realize that if everyone did this, no company could afford to offer programming.  So, I’m wondering…what can be done?  I like the HULU model.  I watch some favorite shows and I can easily stomach the four or five 15 second commercials breaks.  It may be the best compromise.  It will no doubt change how commercials are done.  Product hawking will have to adapt, and I’ve noticed that a few companies are producing fast-paced, edgy commercials designed to fit the 15 second mold.

I’ve long felt that advertizing companies make too much money.  I feel that commercials have gone from “buy our product” spots to “buy our brand” and finally, to self-congratulatory mini theatre.  But thats not the point of my post.  I am wondering if we are going to see less commercials, less original content, and, eventually, a complete re-structuring of television?  I know i won’t watch 10-12 thirty second spots for a half-hour’s entertainment.  I’m willing to compromise, though.

I’m having fun learning about P2P stuff, and bit torrents, and other means of sharing content.  I’m reading all perspectives about it, though, as I haven’t determined what is ethical and what isn’t.  I know I won’t support sites that send someone into a theatre to video-tape a first run movie.  That seems like blatant theft.  But, what is a good rule of thumb regarding music?  If I buy an album, is it okay to put it on cassette and then share it with friends? If I upload it to the web, and say, you are welcome to this, is that not my right?

I guess I’m going to just set an arbitrary amount that I’m willing to pay.  I’m not paying 18 bucks for an album.  I’m not paying 99 cents a song either.  I have, in the past, used a overseas source and paid 15 cents a song, 1.99 an album.  Okay, thats great, but it doesn’t really help here at home.  I’m willing to pay 30 cents a song, and I’m willing to pay a 10 cent tax to do so.  I could be moved to 40 or even 50 cents if someone makes the case.

Starving artist arguments aren’t going to move me one bit.  Is it accurate to say that 99% of musicians toil away in anonymity and relative poverty even without piracy?  The fraction of those that “make it” aren’t always the best or most original.  Should someone that wrote a single hit in their lifetime expect to get rich and stay rich?  The business model is changing, of course, and with it, expectations will have to be whittled down for all concerned, from the label, to the distributor, (they are probably dinosaurs anyway) to the artist themselves.

Like it or not, the internet is going to impact the entertainment industry for the foreseeable future.  Some of us are willing to pay, but we may very well exercise other options once we feel abused.

I have no idea what is fair, or ethical.  I’m willing to listen to arguments.


Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “I DRMed This Post

  1. Amber

    Well, first of all, companies already find a way to advertise by use of product placement. And I’m not sure a DVR is all that different from taping via VHS and I don’t recall that being a big deal. Plus I think lots of companies have gotten savvier about their ads. I watch commercials all the time.

    Regarding someone video taping a movie and
    showing to to millions of people – how is that different from someone putting a cd on the internet so that millions of people can listen without paying for it? And if you think that’s the same as putting an album on tape & sharing it with your friends, you might be like Rainman where everything is $100.

    Your ‘starving artist’ paragraph reads like someone trying to justify something that in their core knows just doesn’t feel right.

    I couldn’t disagree with you more on that point. But I’m sure you probably know that. 🙂

    Clearly though the challenges (& opportunities) the internet brings to or takes from the entertainment industry will change the way everyone does business.

    The internet has been a great liberator for many people and a terrific resource and convenience, but it has indeed come at a VERY dear cost to many industries, entertainment & news in particular – and I think we as a people will feel it.

  2. Well, Heartbreak, I admitted up front that i struggle with some of this. Not -for -profit sharing cannot be stopped. Our laws mean little in Freedonia. If that is a given, and people know it is out there, why on Earth would they pay 18 dollars for an album? Digitized music appeals to me. No carbon footprint, as no trucks required to service brick and mortar retail shops. No packaging to discard. Remember when it was easier to get a CD out of a store than it was to get it out of the packaging?

    Anyway, there are those that make a compelling case against the DVR, too. Product placement ain’t the same as an ad. Back in day, Heartbreak, VHS and cassettes were a HUGE deal.

    Appreciate the perspective, though, youngin. 😉

  3. Amber

    Yeah, I’ve pretty much given up on a discussing this with people for the most part. When people get things for free it’s hard to convince them to pay for it.

    I can just say the old adage is true: How do you make a million dollars in the music business? Start with two million.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s